Wednesday, February 22, 2012

Psychiatric Patients With No Place to Go But Jail

A few days ago, I posted a story about how because of draconian sentences, America's prisons are being turned into retirement homes. Well, now comes a story from The New York Times about how, thanks to state government budget cuts, they may also be being turned into psychiatric wards:
The sounds of chaos bounce off the dim yellow walls. Everywhere there are prisoners wearing orange, red and khaki jumpsuits. An officer barks out orders as a thin woman tries to sleep on a hard bench in a holding cell. This is a harsh scene of daily life inside what has become the state’s largest de facto mental institution: the Cook County Jail.

About 11,000 prisoners, a mix of suspects awaiting trial and those convicted of minor crimes, are housed at the jail at any one time, which is like stuffing the population of Palos Heights into an eight-block area on Chicago’s South Side. The Cook County sheriff, Tom Dart, estimated that about 2,000 of them suffer from some form of serious mental illness, far more than at the big state-owned Elgin Mental Health Center, which has 582 beds.

Mr. Dart said the system “is so screwed up that I’ve become the largest mental health provider in the state of Illinois.” The situation is about to get worse, according to Mr. Dart and other criminal justice experts. The city plans to shut down 6 of its 12 mental health centers by the end of April, to save an estimated $2 million, potentially leaving many patients without adequate treatment — some of them likely to engage in conduct that will lead to arrests.

“It will definitely have a negative impact on jail populations,” said Mr. Dart, who noted that the number of people coming into the jail with mental health problems was already increasing. “It will have direct consequences for us in my general jail population and some of the problems I have here, because a lot of the people with these issues act out more, as you would expect, so that’s a direct consequence.”

It costs an estimated $143 a day to house a typical detainee in the Cook County Jail. The cost to house someone with serious mental health issues is two to three times that amount. Mr. Dart said that prisoners with mental health problems are in a disproportionate number of fights and make more suicide threats, and managing them takes more resources.

“And then there’s the humane side of it,” he said. “Not treating people with mental illness is bad enough, but treating them like criminals? Please, what have we become?”
Indeed, Mr. Dart, what HAVE we become? I ask myself that question nearly every single day.


  1. Bill, sorry for the off topic, but I couldn't find a contact link. Thought you might like this story from the Dallas News which demonstrates our country's miraculous economic expansion.

    1. "Trainor Glass Co., the third largest U.S. construction glass company involved in major projects throughout the Dallas area, has ceased operations."

      I had not seen that article, Anon. Thanks. Yep, sure sounds like a positive economic indicators to me.

  2. In America, every problem of any kind eventually escalates into the criminal justice system (prison/jail).

    I was talking to a fellow at the bus stop tonight who had been arrested from his home and thrown into jail---for parking tickets.

    "Indeed, Mr. Dart, what HAVE we become? I ask myself that question nearly every single day."



  3. The reality is it isn't what we've become. It's what we've always been. We just pay attention hard times. In good times, we're having way too much fun to pay attention to much of anything which is whe we are where we are.

    There's a part of me that's really amused by all the crying about this or that. I clearly remember the irrational exuberance when the insane good times were rolling. The poor, the laid off, the unemployed, the imprisoned mentally ill and all there other things were there just like now.

    My point is: Want it different, pay attention all the time.

  4. Tom Dart is one of the 'good' guys too. He's one of the only Sheriffs in the country that pushed back on doing foreclosures here in Cook Co.
    The problems w/Chicago/Cook jails are one of the big reasons I'm not going to be demonstrating the G8/20 here in May. I try to stay as far away from the uniforms as possible.